Why I Stopped Doing "Will He Come Back?" Readings
Repeatedly asking “Will he come back?” can make it harder to decide what to do next. I share why I stopped doing these readings, the three questions I now suggest, and why I still understand the comfort of hearing a simple yes.
Contents (6)
The Same Question, Several Weeks Running
One woman asked me, “Will he come back?” She asked for several weeks running. Each time I drew different cards. Each time she wanted to hear me say yes.
I can’t tell you which spread made me stop. There wasn’t one. I remember the repetition better than I remember any of the cards.
What This Question Actually Does
By the time I understood what I was giving her, I’d given it to her several times. It was comfort. I kept presenting it as information, though nothing I drew brought me any closer to knowing what this man intended to do.
Suppose your sister offers you the spare room in her flat. You like the neighborhood, the rent works, and she needs your answer by Thursday. On Monday you ask me whether he’ll come back. I say yes. By Thursday you’re trying to remember how serious he sounded when he talked about getting a place together. Your sister gives the room to somebody else. I never told you to turn it down. My answer still had a hand in where you ended up living.
Doing the reading again makes the next decision harder. Say he mails back your key. Now you have a fresh question about whether Monday’s answer still holds. You started with one person whose intentions were hard to read. Now you have his behavior and my last reading to reconcile before you feel entitled to make a decision.
A no gives me just as much authority. If you’re ready to leave, why should you have to keep drawing cards until I say you can go?
The Case for Asking Anyway
Some people mean it literally when they say they need one certain thing to stay alive. Picture getting through a shift by telling yourself he’ll call, then coming home to twelve hours alone. If a reader’s yes is what lets you put the phone down, eat something and turn out the light, those hours count. Asking you to sit with uncertainty costs me considerably less than it costs you.
I might be wrong about what a single reassuring reading costs a person. If somebody tells me a yes got them through a night they were afraid they wouldn’t survive, I believe them. I understand the appeal of hearing one sentence that requires absolutely nothing of you. Even a kind question about your next move can sound like another job when you’ve barely managed dinner.
I still need to be honest about what I can promise. If someone tells me they’re afraid they won’t make it through tonight, I’ll put the cards down and help them call someone who can be there. I can say, “I’ll stay with you while you make that call,” and keep my word without needing anything from him.
What I Ask Instead
“If he doesn’t come back, how will I spend the next three months?” Three months is short enough to put on a calendar. You can answer your sister about the room, work out what the move will cost, and decide where to spend the holidays. You can do all three while privately hoping he calls.
“What can I control in this relationship right now?” Sometimes the answer is small. You can ask a mutual friend to stop forwarding screenshots of his posts. That gives you some say over what arrives on your phone during lunch. It gives your friend a way to help, too.
“Am I waiting for him, or am I waiting for permission?” This is the one I’d ask if you already know you want the room. What exactly would my blessing add? Try telling your sister, “I want to live there.” See whether it sounds true before either of us touches a card.
Who Should Ignore This Advice
If you can ask the question once, hear the answer and get on with your afternoon, I see little reason to interfere. Suppose you draw a yes and your first thought is how much you dread another Sunday lunch with his family. That flicker of reluctance tells you something worth knowing. I’d trust you to decide what to do with it.
And sometimes you’re owed a straight answer. If both your names are on a lease that expires next month, you have every reason to ask whether he’s coming back. I’d take that question to the person whose signature you need and tell him when the landlord needs to know.
What I Still Do When Someone Asks
I let the question stand for a moment. It takes something to admit you’d still like to hear from a person your friends are tired of hearing about. An immediate correction from me would give you one more place where you have to pretend you’re over him.
Then I ask what you were hoping to do after the reading. If the answer is “Call my sister about the room,” we can stay with that. And if two possible answers are all you can manage today, “Do I want to live there?” fits just fine into a yes-or-no tarot reading.